When Should You Repair a Roof vs. Get a New Roof?

A roof is a functional component and a significant architectural feature that contributes to your home’s protection, aesthetics and curb appeal. Over time, however, roofs inevitably undergo wear and tear, raising the crucial question, when should you repair a roof versus get a new roof? 

Let’s dive into it below.

The Lifespan of Different Roofing Materials

When it comes to a roof’s durability and longevity, the type of roofing material used plays a pivotal role. In this section, we will explore how various roofing materials measure up in terms of durability. 

Asphalt shingles: 15-30 years

Asphalt shingles, one of the most common roofing materials, have a lifespan ranging from 15 to 30 years. The longevity of asphalt shingles can vary based on factors such as the quality of the shingles, the climate, and maintenance. 

Wood shingles: 20-25 years

Wood shingles are made from redwood, cedar, spruce, or treated pine, known for their natural resistance to decay and insects. However, over time, wood shingles are affected by weathering, moisture, and UV exposure, causing them to split, crack, or become discolored. 

To maximize their lifespan, ensure regular inspections and maintenance are done. Replace damaged shingles and apply protective coatings or sealants. Also, ensure adequate ventilation in the attic to prevent moisture-related issues that can shorten the life of your wood shingles.

Metal roofs: 50-75 years

Metal roofs are exceptionally durable, with a 50-75-year lifespan and even longer with proper care. Metal roofs are constructed from galvanized steel, aluminum, copper, and other materials, which are resistant to common roofing issues. 

Tile and slate roofs: 50-100 years

There’s good news if you have tile and slate roofs because your roofing is expected to last 50-100 years. These roofs are often made from natural clay or stone, which are exceptionally durable. They are resistant to common issues that often shorten the lifespan of other roofing materials. Their longevity is attributed to their dense composition, making them highly resistant to moisture, rot, and insect damage. 

Flat roofs: 10-20 years

Flat roofs have a shorter lifespan than sloped roofs and are expected to last around 10 to 20 years, although their durability can vary depending on the materials used, climate conditions, maintenance, and quality of installation.

The relatively shorter lifespan of flat roofs can be attributed to their increased vulnerability to water pooling and moisture infiltration. Also, flat roofs are more exposed to the elements, including UV radiation and extreme temperature fluctuations. These environmental factors can cause roofing materials to degrade more quickly.

Signs That Your Roof Needs Attention

Below are some key indicators that should prompt you to take action and address any roofing issues promptly.

Missing, cracked, or curling shingles

The condition of the shingles on your roof is a critical element in maintaining the overall functionality of your roofing system. Here’s a closer look at some warning signs.

Missing shingles. High winds, severe storms, or improper installation are common reasons for shingles to go missing. 

Leaving gaps in your roof exposes the underlying roofing structure to elements like snow and rain, resulting in further damage and more extensive repair costs.

Cracked shingles. Cracking can occur due to exposure to sunlight, temperature fluctuations, hail, or the natural aging of the shingles. 

Curling shingles. Moisture, poor installation, improper installation, and aging can cause your shingles to warp or curl. 

Leaks and water damage in the attic or ceiling

Water damage and leaks in the ceiling or attic are clear indicators that your roof needs urgent repair. 

When only a small area is damaged, repairing can be economical. However, if the damage is extensive, you may need to replace the roof since repair could be more costly.

Major causes include: 

  • Cracks
  • Chimney issues
  • Improperly driven roofing nails
  • Heavy foot traffic on the roof
  • Consistent exposure to elements

Moss, algae, or fungal growth

Another pointer that your roof needs urgent attention is the presence of moss, algae, or fungi. They are unsightly and can harm your roof’s integrity and cause structural damage if left untreated. Physically removing the growth, using roof treatments, or installing zinc or copper strips will inhibit future growth. 

Sagging roof deck

Sagging roof decks can lead to structural issues and potential water damage. They are usually caused by: 

  • Excessive weight accumulated from snow and too many roofing layers
  • Weather conditions such as rain and snow
  • Water damage that infiltrates into the roof support structure, weakening wood and damaging insulation
  • Strong winds that exert significant force on a roof, potentially leading to sagging if the roofing structure is not properly braced or secured

Excessive granule loss from asphalt shingles

Asphalt shingles naturally deteriorate over time due to exposure to the elements. As they age, the adhesive that holds the granules in place weakens, leading to granule loss.  

Causes of granule loss from asphalt shingles include:

  • Exposure to weather elements
  • Low-quality shingles
  • Unnecessary foot traffic on the roof
  • Overhanging trees that drop branches, leaves, and other debris onto your roof.
  • Growth of algae and moss

When to Opt for Repairs

Catching early signs before they worsen will potentially save you from premature roof replacement. Now that you know the average lifespan of each roofing material, it is also important to know when to opt for repairs so your roof can have a longer lifespan. 

Minor Damages: A few missing or damaged shingles, or minor leaks

If you notice a few missing or damaged shingles on your roof, you must have them replaced immediately. Missing shingles can expose the underlying roofing materials to the elements, increasing the risk of leaks and water damage.

Promptly address minor leaks, which can lead to more extensive water damage to your home’s interior, insulation, and structure. Contact a roofing professional to inspect the extent of the damage and replace the affected shingles or perform necessary repairs to stop leaks.

Recent Roofs: If the roof is relatively new and within its expected lifespan

Inspect your roof periodically for signs of damage, such as missing or damaged shingles, minor leaks, or ventilation. If your roof is still under warranty and you notice any defect, contact the manufacturer to fix this issue. 

Budget Constraints: Temporary fixes to buy some time before a full replacement

If you have budget constraints and cannot afford a full roof replacement, consider temporary fixes to address immediate issues and buy some time before committing to a full replacement. 

However, roof issues tend to worsen over time, and delaying necessary repairs or replacement can lead to more extensive and costly damage. 

Localized Damage: Damage limited to a small area, not widespread

Some areas of a roof are more prone to localized damage due to their vulnerability and exposure to the elements. These areas include:

  • Flashing installed around roof penetrations such as chimneys, roof valleys, vents, and skylights
  • Openings in roofs, such as vent pipes, exhaust fans, or satellite dish mounts, can be prone to leaks if not properly sealed
  • Clogged or damaged gutters and downspouts

When to Consider a Full Roof Replacement

Now let’s consider instances where roof replacement is necessary.

End of Lifespan: The roof is approaching or has exceeded its expected lifespan

One of the most common reasons to consider a full roof replacement is when the roof is approaching or has exceeded its expected lifespan. As we have seen above, different roofing materials have varying lifespans, and if your roof is reaching the end of its recommended years of service, it’s a good time to start planning for a replacement. 

If you continue relying on an aging roof, you’ll face increased maintenance costs and a higher risk of leaks.

Major Damage: Extensive water damage, large sections of missing shingles, etc.

If your roof has sustained extensive damage, such as significant water damage, large sections of missing shingles, or structural issues, it may be more cost-effective and practical to opt for a full roof replacement rather than attempting extensive repairs. 

A new roof is better because major damages can compromise the integrity of the entire roofing system. A replacement can provide a fresh start with a reliable and secure roof.

Multiple Previous Repairs: The roof has undergone numerous repairs in a short time

Frequent repair in short successions? It could be that the roofing materials are way past their lifespan. If you look at it carefully, frequent repairs can be costly, and the cumulative expense may make a full roof replacement a more economical choice.

Upgrading Home Value: A new roof can significantly increase a home’s resale value

If you want to sell your house, the best way to increase curb appeal and make your home more appealing to potential buyers is by installing a new roof. This will increase your home’s resale value and help you to sell faster!

Energy Efficiency: Newer roofing materials can be more energy-efficient, saving on utility bills

Newer roofing materials often come with improved energy efficiency features. Upgrading to more energy-efficient roofing options, such as cool roofing systems or insulated roofing materials, can lead to energy savings over time. These savings can offset the roof replacement cost and enhance your home’s comfort and energy efficiency.

Cost Considerations

Roofing projects can vary significantly in cost based on factors like the size and complexity of the roof, choice of materials, geographic location, and the extent of the work needed. Understanding these cost considerations is essential to make an informed decision. 

Consider the following:

  • Repairs might be cheaper now, but multiple repairs over time can cost more than a replacement.
  • New roofs often come with warranties, ensuring peace of mind for years.
  • Investing in a new roof can offer a good return on investment when selling.
  • The selection of materials should align with your budget, long-term goals, and aesthetic preferences.
  • Regular maintenance and prompt repairs can help mitigate future extensive expenses by addressing issues early.

Environmental Considerations

Environmental considerations in roofing are crucial, especially in light of two key factors: waste and energy efficiency. Roof replacements often generate significant waste, but choosing recyclable materials can mitigate this environmental impact. 

Modern roofing options can substantially enhance your home’s energy efficiency by reflecting sunlight and reducing heat absorption. This will lower energy consumption for cooling and minimize your home’s carbon footprint.

Key Takeaway

Making an informed decision is crucial, whether you’re facing minor repairs, localized damages, or contemplating a full roof replacement. Your choices can have long-lasting consequences for your home’s durability, value, and environmental impact.

Consult with roofing professionals with the expertise and experience to assess your roofing needs. They’ll provide invaluable insights, recommend appropriate materials and solutions, and offer cost-effective maintenance or replacement strategies. 

Don’t wait for roofing issues to worsen! Schedule a professional roof inspection now to safeguard your home.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top